W.'s favourite Hindu stories are those of tragic decline, he says. The doctrine of the Four Ages, for example, he says. He likes that. In the first Age, virtue, dharma is like a four legged cow, in the second, like a three legged one, and so on, W. says. And in our age, the lowest age, the cow can only hop about on one leg.
W. wants another tragic Hindu story, he says. This one, I promise him, will conclude with his favourite line from the Maharabharta, 'and darkness fell over India'. And darkness fell over India: that's the way to end an epic, W. says.
Years have passed since the great battle of Kurukshetra. The Pandava brothers have ruled wisely and justly for decades. Then comes word that Krishna – the avatar of the divine, who was born on earth to fight for virtue – has been killed. Krishna's death means only one thing, the Pandavas know. The third Age had be succeeded by the fourth, the lowest, the Age of Iron. Now it was time for them to renounce the world.
The Pandavas and their wife depart from their kingdom as pilgrims, dressed in animal skins, heading through the mountains towards heaven.
'Their wife – you mean they only had one wife?', says W. One wife, I tell him. Draupadi.
At some point on their journey – none of them is quite sure when – a stray dog begins to follow them at a distance. Shouldn't such an unclean beast be driven away? Let it come with us!, says Yudhishitra. Perhaps it, too, is weary of earthly existence. It seems even a dog can know the end is coming.
Their journey is a terrible one, full of dangers. The path rises steadily upwards; a blizzard sets in. Draupadi, their wife, has disappeared. She must have fallen, they lament. But how could that be? The path to heaven is a test, says Yudhishitra, the oldest and wisest of the Pandavas. You have to be without sin, pure of heart, if Indra is to carry you there in your bodily form.
Why, then, did Draupadi fall? What sin had she committed?, His brothers ask. Because she did not love her husbands equally, Yudhishitra says. Of the five of us, she favoured Arjuna.
They press on, the road leading ever upwards. Then, suddenly, the two youngest brothers, Nakula and Sahadeva, are swept away by the wind. The remaining brothers hears their cries as they fall. How could Nakula and Sahadeva deserve such a death?, his brothers ask Yudhishitra. Weren't they wholly virtuous, wholly without blame? Ah, but they were vain and proud of their looks, Yudhishitra says. That's why they fell.
The brothers press on again, as the path rises yet higher, and the whole field of the Himalayas spreads beneath them. Then, in quick succession, the great warriors Bhima and Arjuna fall from the path. Why did they fall?, Yudhishitra asks himself, the stray dog still beside him. How could his brothers have failed the test? But he knows the answer: they were too proud, Bhima of his skills with the mace, Arjuna of his with the bow. So they, too, had to fall.
'Why would you have fallen?', W. asks me. He knows why he would have fallen, he says. His stupidity, his laziness. The way he's failed his friends. He thinks of one of them who is sunk in autistic isolation, of another lost in perpetual self-doubt, and still another who has exiled himself to a culture where no one understands him.
What has he done for them?, W. laments. Nothing to make them greater. Nothing to help them. Nothing to redeem himself, in all his mediocrity. What a failure he is!, W. sighs. Ah, that's why he would have fallen.
But then I wouldn't even have on the journey, W. says. I would never have even set out. The fourth Age, the Age of Iron would have suited me just fine, W. says. I would never have tried to leave it behind. Anyway, he says, get on with it.
On and on the path winds, I continue, struggling towards the glistening mountain peak where Indra, King of the gods, waits to transport the faithful to heaven. How strange that I have outlived Draupadi and my brothers!, Yudhishitra says to himself. How strange to be all alone!
Then he sees it: Indra's golden chariot, glistening in the distance. Heartened by the sight of the end of his journey, Yudhishitra runs up what remains of the path, the stray dog behind him. Indra stands before him. Will you take me to heaven, Lord?, asks Yudhishitra. You may come with me, Indra says, but your dog may not.
But I have taken the dog under my protection, Yudhishitra says. He and I are the only survivors, and he has been my loyal companion. Could he not accompany me for the final stage of my journey? But Indra shakes his head.
Loyalty, W. says. He understands that even as he lacks it. Have I been following him on his philosophical journey? Is he leading me upward, onward, against all my instincts, which are taking me irrevocably downwards and backwards?
Then a thought horrifies him: has he been following me, albeit not on a philosophical journey, but on an anti-philosophical one? Is the road upward – his road – really only a road downward – my road? Is his road onward leading hm only on my road backwards? Anyway, go on.
Without this dog, I continue, I will not enter heaven, says Yudhishitra, with great firmness. At that moment, a miraculous transformation occurs. In place of the dog, there stands the god Dharma, the very incarnation of virtue. Yudhishitra bows his head. Indra, too, bows his.
I was testing you, Yudhishitra, says Dharma. Because you would not relinquish your protection of the least creature, I know your virtue. You are worthy of entering heaven.
Yudhishitra leaves the earthly domain behind in Indra's chariot. How glad he is to have escaped the Age of Iron! How glad to have left behind a world with no avatar to steer it towards virtue!
The gates of heaven open before him, and Yudhishitra is carried into the light. For a time, he stands quite dazzled. But when his tired eyes adjust to the light, he is horrified by what lies before him. His former enemies – the very foes he and his brothers had destroyed at the battle of Kurukshetra - laugh and feast at great tables, whilst his brothers and his wife are nowhere to be seen.
Draupadi and your brothers are in hell, atoning for their sins, Indra says. We are all sinners, Yudhishitra thinks to himself, and perhaps each of us must spend a little time in hell atoning for our sins. But why, then, are our enemies, the very enemies of dharma, as Krishna called them, feasting in heaven?
Has Indra gone mad? Does Krishna's death mean the end of justice in heaven as well as earth? It is not only Kings who rule unwisely in the Age of Iron – gods, too! It seems as though Kali, the lord of confusion, has taken the place of Dharma himself.
Take me to my wife and my brothers, Yudhishitra says to Indra. Take me to hell.
Hell, says W. That's what happens when friend turns upon friend. Disloyalty! Careerism! Didn't I send him a print by Daniel Johnson called In Hell There Are No Friends? – 'No friends!', says W. 'Or only friends like you'.
Hell is a fearsome place, I continue. It reminds Yudhishitra of the last days of the battle at Kurukshetra, when blood and gore covered the battlefield and smoke rose from countless fires. He hears voices crying out for the misery to end. He hears voices lamenting their eternal damnation.
This is what the world itself will become, he thinks to himself, in the last of the Ages. Strife and chaos are everywhere. Who now can remember the rituals surrounding the sacrifice? Who the very name of God?
At last, he hears the voices of his brothers among the hubbub. He hears Draupadi, crying in pain. He's found them, and is glad. Will you return with me to heaven?, Indra says. It is where you belong. No, says Yudhishitra. It is better to remain in a hell of good souls than a heaven of evil ones. Here I will stay.
Then, in a flash, Krishna himself, now in his spiritual form, and in whom Yudhishtra can see the whole universe and all the gods, appears before him. The Pandava falls to his knees. Around him – another miracle - what was hell is now heaven. His brothers and his wife feast and laugh, and there is no sign of their former foes.
That was your last test, Krishna tells him. You have shown yourself to be truly virtuous. And then – in a moment unprecedented in the Maharabharta – he bows to Yudhishtra in tribute to his dharma, divinity bowing to humanity, the last avatar to the last virtuous man. And then come the closing lines of the epic, the most moving of all: and darkness fell over India.
'And darkness fell over India', W. says. 'You were born'.